The Budget: Twitter ye not

Recently I’ve been making use of Twitterfall, a tool that helps you keep track of what’s been said on a particular subject, across the Twitter world. Basically, it allows you to monitor a particular set of hashtags (#), which twitterers use to identify the subject of a posting. The ‘fall’ part describes the way in which posts with the monitored tag arrive from Twitter – they visually drop down a window on your screen.

Yesterday there was great merriment across the blogosphere over the Telegraph’s experiment with hosting a twitterfall window within their own webpages which was set to monitor the hashtag #budget. The problem was that large numbers of people saw this as an unmoderated way to add content to the Telegraph website by posting all sorts of nonsense to Twitter and simply adding the #budget tag. The Guardian’s media blog in particular had enormous fun at their rival’s expense, and I particularly liked the spoof comment that Barclays had agreed to pay all our personal tax bills.

Unfortunately, the general consensus seems to be that Telegraph staffers are a bunch of techno-illiterates who don’t understand the world of Twitter. But wait a minute, isn’t this a bit harsh? Surely this shows they believe in the power of the crowd to pull together and perform better than any one individual? Perhaps the Telegraph deserve some respect for hoping that people would utilise some personal self-restraint and actually post something of value about the budget. All this demonstrates is that Andrew Keen is right – we’re really not ready for an ‘unedited’ future.


Tags: , , ,

2 Responses to “The Budget: Twitter ye not”

  1. olvado Says:

    The Telegraph have actually been publishing Twitterfalls on their site for a while now, though none as high profile as yesterday’s. They have featured football team related Twitter feeds on their match ‘live text’ pages, enabling conversations around live football matches. These have not been abused the same way as might expect.

    It would be a shame if these were also removed with them fearing the same abuse again.

    The obvious answer would be to moderate tweets, though does this go against the Twitter ethos? And of course you’ve got to get someone to moderate them!

    • pdanderson Says:

      Hi Olvado

      Interesting to learn that other twitter feeds have not been abused – especially as football is notoriously ‘vigorous’ 🙂 Also an interesting question of whether to moderate twitter – I don’t think the twitterfall tool allows this.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: